2Malaysia - where double standards prevail

NAMEWEE IS A UNITING FACTOR
Mariam Mokhtar
Malaysian Mirror, Friday, 03 September 2010 08:5

COMMENT If Namewee (Wee Meng Chee) is prosecuted for his music-video, then two mixed messages are being sent out by the government: The first is that the authorities practise double-standards. The second is that it was only because of Namewee's 'intervention' that the government sat up and took racism seriously.

On Wednesday, it was reported that the rapper was being investigated by the police for sedition. Various ministers and a menteri besar also want Namewee punished for his controversial video.

In the first place, Namewee made this clip because of the government's slow response to tackle effectively the latest racist incident. It appears that we are now united, against racism. Far from being seditious or racist, Namewee has done the job of the government in exposing all that is 'ugly' about us.

Just over two weeks ago, the Johore school headmistress featured in Namewee's clip made serious, humiliating and crude remarks to non-Malay students in her school. The prime minister, who coined the term 1Malaysia, took two weeks to make any comment regarding this issue. In the meantime, the damage became magnified.

Finally, Najib said that when it came to racism, he wanted 'zero-tolerance' and a 'swift response' to people who made racial slurs. It appears that the prime minister has fallen at the first hurdle. There was not a quick, speedy response, as promised. It took him a very slow two weeks before issuing a statement. For another, why has the police investigation been allowed to drag?

But let us imagine that for one moment, it was a non-Malay school head who had uttered derogatory remarks about her Malay pupils and told them to 'pergi balik bawah tempurung' (return to your place beneath your coconut shell) or that the tudung worn by the girls was only to cover-up their 'bad hair-do'.

Wisdom and tolerance

I need not mention how the Malay community, egged on by the Ketuanan Melayu clowns, would react by picketing, protesting and practically foaming at the mouth.If anything, the Johore school incident proved that the non-Ma lay community has shown extreme restraint and should be commended for their wisdom and tolerance.

The shame is that few Malays voiced their objections to the disgusting remarks of the Malay school-heads (both in Johore and Kedah). Where are the voices of condemnation for these racist rants? Are they afraid of pilloried by members of their own community? Or have they no principles? And lack a conscience?

Namewee is reacting to the slow response of the government to tackle racism. Hence, it is the government who has failed the Malaysian public. It is Namewee who conveyed the important message to Malaysians, in an entertaining way via his Youtube clip, that 'racism sucks'. To date, what is the progress into the school-head investigation? How long does it take to get eye-witness statements?

People forget that Namewee is a rapper. He produces videos and music videos. Rap music may glorify violence, misogyny, drug abuse and homophobia. Profanity and vulgar language are common. Like it or not, rap or hip hop, is the language of the young these days. With rap, he has managed to engage with the young, to 'say 'no' to racism'. Any parent of a teenager will know what I am talking about. The songs teenagers listen to these days, often colour the air-waves blue.

One can only imagine Namewee's rage at the slow official response to tackle racism. It is the same fury that overcomes us when we are lectured by our political masters to do, think and talk '1Malaysia' but then discover to our shock, that some ministers do not practise it.

Admittedly, Namewee is simply expressing his anger and frustration in creativity and music, just like Eminem or Jay-Z. It is highly unlikely that our aging ministers will understand nor appreciate rap music.
Namewee is the perfect entertainer and has sound business acumen. Sometimes, to shock may even sell more records. He has gained increased publicity for himself being enterprising.

Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin adopted a different spin on Namewee's questions: "You tak baca? Siapa buat Malaysia kaya?" (Don't you know? Who made Malaysia prosperous?). Khairy assumed that Namewee suggested the 'Malays played a minor role in Malaysia's economic growth'.

Khairy is possibly wrong and as far as can be ascertained, Namewee wasn't alluding to anything.
Namewee posed an open-ended question. However, political personalities are already scoring brownie points by insinuating various things.

Namewee was wrong to be abusive – even I would balk short at such behaviour. But Namewee speaks for all those who suffered that day in school and for the people in Malaysia who care. Maybe if the authorities had been swift in their response, Namewee would not have had the reason to come up with this clip.

The more potent danger

Actually, Namewee has done the job of the government much better that the government itself. It has given prominence to racism issues in a creative way and made us take a stand against racism. If not for his Youtube, clip, would we have taken as much attention? The problem is that the authorities have 'lost it'.

When Dr Chua Soi Lek criticised Namewee and said, "Freedom of expression should come with responsibility to consider sensitivities towards other races and religions", he forgot that it was the two school principals who ignored sensitivities and caused a furore. And instead of the school principals being censured, it is Namewee who is allegedly being charged with sedition. Namewee's clip was crude and coarse, but not racist.

This young disgruntled Malaysia's response to racism has been blown into something of a racial firestorm. That is the more potent danger. It seems that when you scratch beneath the surface, 1Malaysia is unraveling faster than a knitted jumper. One person condemns an irresponsible racist head, and the so called defenders of the race, react like beasts unleashed, and all for the wrong reasons.

Namewee has talent. He engages with the young via his rap music and lyrics. He should be nominated for a role in the Ministry for Information, Communications, Cul­ture and Arts, to promote racial unity and other Malaysian issues.

Far from creating disharmony, Namewee has united us against racism. He at least has the courage to tackle racism in his own entertaining way.

The Ahmad Ismail saga - the beginning of the end of Pak Lah

Umno suspends Ahmad three years (Update 3)

(The Star Online, 10 September 2008) KUALA LUMPUR: Umno has suspended Bukit Bendera division chief Datuk Ahmad Ismail three years over his alleged racist remarks about the Chinese.

The decision was reached at a special meeting of the Umno supreme council held at the PWTC Wednesday afternoon. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi chaired the meeting that lasted almost three hours.

As a result of the suspension, Ahmad will be stripped of all party posts and voting rights. He will remain an ordinary member however.

Abdullah told a press conference after the meeting that the Cabinet at its meeting Wednesday also discussed racial relations in the country.

“The Cabinet feels that racial tension may arise if sensitive issues are raised. The Cabinet has ordered ministries with laws pertaining to this to enforce them.

“If it is necessary, the ISA may be used on those who stoke racial tension,” he added.

Abdullah also told Barisan Nasional component parties to be firm and take disciplinary action on their members, who also made statements that stoked racial sentiments.

The meeting was held after Barisan component parties said they wanted “immediate and stern action” to be taken against Ahmad during a meeting of the coalition’s supreme council on Tuesday afternoon.

However, because it involved a party matter, they left it to Umno to act.

After stopping 10 busloads of his supporters on their way to the Putra World Trade Centre where the supreme council meeting was held, Ahmad said he would not retract his statements, but urged his supporters and all Malays to remain calm.

At a press conference, he said he accepted Umno supreme council's decision to suspend him, but added he would "make a comeback."

He accused Gerakan acting president Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon of “raising temperatures” on the issue of race relations.

Dr Koh was one of the many leaders who had asked Ahmad to apologise to the Chinese community.

He also denied that he had torn down a picture of Dr Koh at a press conference on Monday.

The Prime Minister had said on Tuesday that the issue had caused uneasiness, worry and anger among the people.

“Some (component parties) expressed their disappointment over what transpired while some showed anger.

“All of us are of the view that Ahmad’s comments are not acceptable at all. What he said has caused anger and concern among the people, non-bumiputras and bumiputras alike, not just in the peninsula but also in Sabah and Sarawak,” Abdullah told reporters on Tuesday.

Ahmad stirred a hornet’s nest recently when he said in a speech while campaigning for the Permatang Pauh by-election that the Chinese were immigrants in the country and did not deserve equal treatment.

Despite criticisms from various community leaders, he refused to apologise.

********************

We will wait, says Gerakan

(The Star, 10 September 2008) KUALA LUMPUR: Gerakan will wait for Umno’s decision on Bukit Bendera Umno division chief Datuk Ahmad Ismail before taking the next course of action, said its acting president Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon.

Asked how he would continue leading his party in Penang since Gerakan has severed all ties with the state Umno after Ahmad’s latest attack against him, Dr Koh said Gerakan would wait for further developments.

The Umno supreme council will hold a special meeting today to decide on Ahmad’s fate after the Barisan Nasional component parties called for Ahmad to be dealt with for his remarks that the Chinese were merely “squatters”, leading to a spat between Penang Umno and Gerakan and MCA.

“We will wait for the Umno supreme council’s decision and evaluate the situation. This is not about one party but two sides,” Dr Koh told reporters after the Barisan supreme council meeting yesterday.

He was asked the action deemed appropriate to be taken against Ahmad and what if Ahmad was merely suspended.

He said the component party leaders had suggested the type of action Umno should take but agreed to leave it to Umno to handle and decide.

“Our way has always been to refer disciplinary cases to the component party concerned to act on, and as the Prime Minister has said, stern and quick action will be meted out,” he said.

To a question, he said it was not that Gerakan had no stand on how Ahmad should be dealt but that it was a well tested principle of Barisan “whereby we make certain suggestions but we don’t want to announce them, instead respect the party concerned to decide.”

He referred to the 2002 case of Penang MCA assemblymen Tan Cheng Liang and Lim Boo Chang who were suspended indefinitely after the Barisan supreme council decided that MCA should take action against them for not voting against an Opposition motion in the state assembly.

Dr Koh, however, said all the component parties, including Umno, had reached a deeper understanding and commitment that the incident should never be allowed to recur.

“All component leaders unanimously expressed their stand that Ahmad’s remarks, statements and behaviour were utterly inappropriate,” he said, adding that they, however, accepted the stand by Prime Minister and Barisan chairman Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, his deputy Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and other Umno leaders present that Ahmad’s stand and approach did not reflect Umno and Barisan’s policy.

On Ahmad’s continued insistence that Dr Koh was to blame for the entire episode, Dr Koh said: “It is up to him but what was decided at this meeting is what is important.”

On whether the Chinese community would be willing to accept the Barisan decision, he said Abdullah’s reassuring statement should be taken positively.

********************

Penang BN Youth chief resigns over photo tearing incident
Himanshu Bhatt

GEORGE TOWN (The SUN, Sept 9, 2008): Penang Barisan Nasional (BN) youth chief Huan Cheng Guan has tendered his resignation after holding the post for six years.

Huan Cheng Guan

Huan, who is also Penang Gerakan youth head, said he sent an SMS on his decision to BN national youth head Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Tun Hussein and Gerakan acting president Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon at about midnight on Monday.

He said he felt compelled to resign because of the behaviour of Umno members who had torn Koh’s photo in a press conference by Umno Bukit Bendera division head Datuk Ahmad Ismail on Monday afternoon.

"I cannot tolerate the tearing up of the photo of my party president and stepping on it," Huan said when contacted today.

"This is not our culture. We have been component parties for so long, we can sit down and talk."

Asked about the future of the state BN youth, Huan quipped: "If these type of people are in the BN, you just think for yourself what the future will be. If they don’t correct their attitude, don’t even dream of going for elections."

********************

Pictures courtesy Kwong Wah Yit Poh

Ahmad Ismail: I did no wrong; reporter to blame for inaccurate reporting
Opalyn Mok

GEORGE TOWN (The SUN, Sept 5, 2008): Bukit Bendera Umno division chief Datuk Ahmad Ismail today addressed the recent uproar over his alleged racist statement by again insisting he did no wrong and instead blamed a Sin Chew Daily reporter for inaccurate reporting of his speech delivered during a ceramah at the Permatang Pauh by-election campaign.

"I do not dispute the fact that I did say that the Chinese were merely 'menumpang di tanah air kita' (squatters in our land) but I was referring to the pre-Merdeka period when Malaya was under the British," he told a packed press conference at Menara Umno here.

Ahmad reiterated confidently that he was not wrong as according to historical facts, it was undeniable that the Chinese were immigrants and squatting on our land during the pre-Merdeka period.

"I did not create any racial issue. It is the reporter who manipulated my speech and he is the one with his own agenda," he said.

Ahmad went on to attack the reporter for not being ethical and for intentionally creating a sensitive issue.

"So the reporter is the one who is responsible in creating this racial issue. It is the reporter who is racist, not me," he said amidst cheers and calls from some Umno members present who shouted the words 'Suruh dia balik tong san' (Tell him to go back to China).

When contacted for an immediate reaction, Sin Chew Daily editor-in-chief Pook Ah Lek told theSun that they stand by their report, and that it was an accurate coverage of what was said.

He said the report was written by a senior journalist who received an in-house excellence award for reportage last year.

The report churned up a furore among Barisan Nasional components MCA and Gerakan, and the DAP joined in as well, to slam Ahmad for his racist remarks. A number of police reports were also lodged, alleging an offence under the Sedition Act.

Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak, who was reportedly present during Ahmad's controversial speech, had on Tuesday tendered a public apology on behalf of Umno for Ahmad's remarks, adding that it was not reflective of Umno's policy.

Ahmad however said Sin Chew Jit Poh had manipulated his speech on Aug 24 and on Aug 25 he had given another ceramah at the Barisan Nasional Bukit Indera Muda Operations Centre and had given an explanation to rectify the issue.

"Why didn't the reporter pick up and rectify the issue? This clearly showed that the reporter has his own agenda," he said.

Continuing with his 'attack' on the reporter, Ahmad said he believed that the reporter was not a reporter who usually covers political issue but had taken over a friend's duty.

"The question now is that surely the newspaper's editor checked the reporter's report. So, I hereby firmly state that I will not apologise over the mistakes made by the reporter. I am innocent and I challenge anyone who wants to disagree with me that the Chinese were 'squatters' in Malaya before Merdeka," he said.

"I am firm with my statement. The reporter should be the one apologising, not only to the Chinese for deliberately creating a racial issue but he should also apologise to me, my family and all the Malays and Muslims in our country," he said.

Reading out from a prepared 16-page speech, Ahmad also demanded for apologies from all Chinese leaders who had issued comments recklessly and blindly which further blew the whole issue out of proportion.

"This includes the Chinese leaders within Barisan Nasional," he said.

Datuk Ahmad Ismail pressing home a point during his press conference to address the furore over a report of his alleged racist remarks.

Ahmad then went on to criticise Gerakan acting president Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon for getting carried away and losing his judgement by releasing immature comments on the issue.

"Koh has tried to shift the focus on his weaknesses by stating that this issue is the cause of Barisan Nasional's loss in Permatang Pauh," he said.

"I challenge Koh to look at himself in the mirror and not to try to find a scapegoat and stop being so dramatic, which he is very good at. He should accept the reality

that the Chinese no longer support him and Gerakan so he should not be looking for a scapegoat," he added.

Ahmad also ticked off three Gerakan leaders from the Bukit Bendera division, whom he did not name, and told them to look ahead.

"In this issue, they have made statements in the Chinese newspapers but we, Malays, have read the translations. We feel saddened and very angry that after 18 years we, the Malays, supported them, they dare to politicise this issue and it is clearly they who are trying to conduct a character assassination, together with several other Chinese leaders, of Malay leaders in Bukit Bendera," he said.

"Or perhaps Koh and Gerakan has their own agenda of late and they are only looking for excuses and reasons to realise their agenda. What agenda? You think about it yourself," he added.

Ahmad also said: "I wish to remind my leaders not to be too weak and extreme in trying to take care of the feelings of others until the feelings of Malays were hurt." He urged them to be strong, firm and not to follow in others' footsteps.

In Penang, he said it is a reality that a majority of the Chinese community do not support Barisan Nasional, which was obvious when, in the March general election, Gerakan and MCA lost all the seats they contested in.

"Don't forget that out of the 15 seats that Umno contested in, 11 seats were given full support by the Malays. Don't be too eager in taking care of the feelings of other races that we are seen to be weak to the point of hurting the feelings of Malays who had supported us all this while," he said.

"Malay leaders must wake up and realise now that we have to unite to uphold the rights and pride of our race," he said.

Later, when asked to respond to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi's statement asking him to apologise, Ahmad said he respects and loves the Prime Minister. "With all due respect to Abdullah, as a BN leader I still have my own principles in certain areas so I will still stand by my statement in not apologising."

As for the Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Najib Abdul Razak's public apology on his behalf, Ahmad said it is Najib's right to apologise.

Asked to respond to a statement by Koh in Kota Baru that Gerakan will review its position in BN if the component parties, especially Umno, fail to bring about change so as to restore people's confidence in the ruling coalition, Ahmad said if Koh and Gerakan wants to leave BN, they can do so.

WHAT AHMAD SAID AT THE CERAMAH

Earlier in his speech, Ahmad started off by stating that he is not a racist and that he has many Chinese and Indians who are not only in politics, sports or business but also in his daily life.

"I am not going to be apologetic. I am not going to apologise as I did not owe any apology to anyone in this issue. I have done nothing wrong," he said.

He claimed that he had been put on trial in the 'media court' where the media had found him guilty which is unfair and unprofessional for not getting any clarification from him while straightaway penalising him.

"I am supposed to be 'innocent until proven guilty' but unfortunately, this did not happen. Worse still, there are some Chinese extremist who has branded myself as a racist. However, there are many Malays who considered me as a nationalist," he said.

He admitted that he had chosen to be silent on the issue in the past week as he had wanted to assess the situation and the development that follows.

"During that period, I was also in Bangkok, Thailand. But during that period, I have discussed with my friends and today, I am ready to give response to the issue. This enabled me to make a decision that is not too rushed or hasty unlike some Chinese leaders who had made baseless comments which reflects

their immaturity and had helped fan this whole baseless issue," he said.

He explained that his ceramah was held for a Malay and Muslim group.

"As a less significant leader, I was trying to create awareness amongst those in my race and religion so it is not wrong for me to talk to them about the fight for Malays and Muslims as it is within Umno's constitution that we fight for Malays' and Muslims' rights," he said.

He further read out what he had said in the ceramah which is a recounting of the history of Malaya during the time of the British rule.

"I said Malaya belonged to our Malay ancestors. The Chinese were only squatting in Malaya at that time, and that due to the unfairness of the British at that time, the immigrant race had received education and more benefits earlier than Bumiputras," he said.

He also said that in achieving Merdeka, the Malays had willingly allowed citizenship to the Chinese and this right was allowed the Chinese when the Chinese at that time agreed to Malay rights and supremacy which must not be disputed.

"This is a social contract agreed by our leaders at that time. Citizenship rights were given to the Chinese as a package whereby the Chinese must accept and respect the rights of the Malays and Malay supremacy.

"The Chinese can't just accept citizenship and later dispute the Malay rights and supremacy as this is breach of contract," he said.

He also pointed out that if the Chinese wants to dispute the Malays rights and supremacy, then in the same context, the Malays also can dispute the rights of the Chinese's citizenship here.

Several Umno leaders who were at the press conference, such as state Umno liaison committee deputy chairman Datuk Seri Abdul Rashid Abdullah and Opposition leader Datuk Azhar Ibrahim also voiced their support for Ahmad for his stand of not apologising.

Keng Yaik admits to beggary

BN component parties 'like beggars', says Keng Yaik

PETALING JAYA (May 12, 2008): Gerakan adviser Datuk Seri Dr Lim Keng Yaik has likened MCA, Gerakan and MIC to "beggars" in the Barisan Nasional (BN) as the coalition did not treat its component parties equitably.

Criticising the lack of equitability in BN, Lim stressed that although the constitution guarantees the special rights of the Malays, it also safeguards the rights of non-Malays.

He said he believed that the people, who had indicated in the recent general election their desire for multi-racial parties to work together, would also want the BN to become a multi-racial political set-up which treats all people equitably.

Lim said this in an interview with Sin Chew Daily in which he gave his views on the new political order in the country and the shape of things to come.

The former Gerakan president and former Energy, Water and Communications Minister predicted that Umno-led BN's model of cooperation will be discarded by the people one day.

He also foresaw that the coalition will change the way it operates given another two general elections.

He felt that under such circumstances, race-based parties like Umno, MCA and MIC will have to disband if BN goes multi-racial.

He said over-emphasis on cooperation among race-based parties will not make the people comfortable.

The people not only hope to see BN become a coalition of multi-racial parties but also want BN to play roles that reflect its multi-racial characteristics.

Lim pointed out that 39 years after the May 13, 1969, riots, the people have seen through the domination of a race-based party.

He said the fact that there was no repeat of the (May 13) bloodshed when the Opposition won big this time around showed the maturity of the people.

He said although Gerakan espouses political multi-racialism, it suffered a major setback in the general election mainly because its candidates were fielded in non-Malay-majority constituencies.

"Why were the non-Malays angry with BN? (It's) Because of the arrogance of Umno, the dominant party in BN. Many people also felt uneasy with the racist remarks made by Umno leaders. These had also caused all BN component parties to suffer in the polls."

He believed that if BN takes the multi-racial path, at least Umno leaders would be more careful with what they say in the future.